
Originally Posted by
labblab
Amanda, I think all of your questions are excellent ones! Lori has given you some very useful quotes re: the LDDS and the effect of stress on that test. As far as the preferability of performing the LDDS vs. the ACTH, I cannot argue with first repeating the LDDS. This is because, of the two tests, it is more likely to produce a positive result if a dog does have Cushing’s. However, if Yohnny *again* tests negative on the LDDS, I’d want to give the ACTH a try since he has so many symptoms that are consistent with the disease. Since the two tests are measuring different aspects of adrenal function, occasionally one will be negative while the other is positive. Here’s a quote by noted endocrinologist, Dr. David Briyette:
So as you can see, it’s only a small chance (5 - 10%) that a dog with Cushing’s will test negative on the LDDS, and that’s why the LDDS is preferred by most specialists to be run first. But in Yohnny’s case, if he tests negative again, I’d want to give the ACTH a try. As far as the ACTH and low cortisol, yes, it’s true that the ACTH is the preferred test for Addison’s disease — your vet is right about that.
Regarding Cushing’s and proteinuria: if Cushing’s is the underlying cause, you definitely want to treat the Cushing’s to keep the condition from worsening. However, Cushing’s treatment alone may not resolve the existing proteinuria, so the two conditions may be treated in tandem. We’ve had several dogs here who have received both treatments. One note about that: I mentioned earlier that Ace inhibitors can elevate potassium levels. Vetoryl (trilostane), the medication that you’d undoubtedly use to treat Cushing’s, can also elevate potassium. So when the two medications are prescribed at the same time, you do have to regularly check blood chemistries to make sure that the potassium level isn’t getting too high. But we’ve had dogs here who have done fine with both.
Overall, aside from performing other tests at the same time as the LDDS, I think the steps that the new vet has recommended are reasonable. And who knows, maybe she intends to do the other tests after the LDDS has concluded (drawing additional blood at the end of the test, for instance, and drawing the urine afterwards). If so, that should be fine and shouldn’t affect the LDDS results. But I totally understand why you don’t want to leave any stone unturned. I’d be the same way if Yohnny were my own. If you’d always wonder whether you would have had more confidence in the recommendations of the other vet, and consulting with the other vet is possible, then you may well wish to do so. I definitely suppprt you 100% whichever way you choose to go!
Marianne